You realize that in the article you sent me it said that the Russian economy is shrinking, right? The only thing they export is petroleum products, coal and iron while they import everything else basically.
https://oec.world/en/profile/country/rus
The thing you might forget is we don’t export population, we export actual manufactured goods, medicine, advanced electronics, aviation equipment, automotive, airbag sensors etc.
I’d argue the problems The West ™ is facing are mostly due to late stage capitalism rather than the sanctions against Russia. We can get our dinosaur products elsewhere.
I’m looking forward to what the future might bring for all of us. Don’t forget we live on the same planet. And keep an open mind.
the problems The West ™ is facing are mostly due to late stage capitalism rather than sanctions against Russia
Edit for effortpost: the fact that late stage capitalism and impotent sanctions coincide is no coincidence. I find LSC a poorly defined term, considering that imperialism seems NOT be considered in the term but only internal indications, but I digress. These two developments, one of corruption from capital and crises developing and the other of sanctions having no benefit and only seeing blowback, are dialectically intertwined. Sanctions could work if western imperialism hadn’t developed to an extent that all necessary labour can be done outside of the core for cheaper. But the efforts to maintain the standards of living and fight external pressure are resulting from the same process and the failures are inseparable also
I’d be willing to say:
mostly due to late stage capitalism
But I’m not sold on the imperialism aspect when both parties are doing it. Although I’d distinguish if they’re doing it with the pen or with the sword. It’d be better without, but I sure do prefer the pen.
Meh, I disagree but this is too tangential from the rest of the thread for me to work too hard in a response. Not sure what you’re even arguing tbh, except that peaceful imperialism is different and America does that. I think all facts point to that being absolutely false, even if the violence is done quietly and in a normalized fashion. I also just disagree that Russia here is Imperialist with a big “I” (different from having a empire, which is confusing often). I also have no idea what this has to do with whether sanctions are succeeding or failing or not. My point is only that the failure of the sanctions and the results of capitalism are from the identical source which is capitalism and the logic of that extended through imperialism to international relations
You realize that in the article you sent me it said that the Russian economy is shrinking, right?
You realize that IMF and pretty much everyone else now says that it’s growing, but I guess you just want to cling to your narrative by cherry picking a paragraph from an article that fits into what you believe.
The thing you might forget is we don’t export population, we export actual manufactured goods, medicine, advanced electronics, aviation equipment, automotive, airbag sensors etc.
Yeah, and cheap energy from Russia was the reason Germany was able to produce these things competitively. Now, input costs for German manufacturing are surging leading to deindustrialization as companies move operations to cheaper energy markets. This is how capitalism works.
I’d argue the problems The West ™ is facing are mostly due to late stage capitalism rather than the sanctions against Russia. We can get our dinosaur products elsewhere.
Late stage capitalism is obviously the underlying reason why the west as a whole is failing. However, having a significant increase in energy costs is clearly a catalyst for the current disaster that Europe is experiencing. These things are in no way mutually exclusive. The economy was structured around cheap energy and doing a lot of trade with Russia and China. Now all of a sudden cheap energy from Russia is gone, and US is leaning on Europe to decouple from China. This is a huge economic readjustment that’s happening rapidly. This is leading to companies closing down, jobs being lost, living expenses going up, and so on.
I’m looking forward to what the future might bring for all of us. Don’t forget we live on the same planet. And keep an open mind.
We do live on the same planet, and that’s precisely why the west needs to start treating the rest of humanity on equal terms instead of trying to dominate the world. Western policies are directly responsible for the climate catastrophe, and western lifestyle continues to be one of the primary drivers of global emissions. Instead of focusing on this global disaster that affects us all, the west decided to fight a proxy war with Russia, and US is increasingly trying to provoke a conflict with China now. People living in the west really need to do some self reflection.
You realize that in the article you sent me it said that the Russian economy is shrinking, right? The only thing they export is petroleum products, coal and iron while they import everything else basically. https://oec.world/en/profile/country/rus
The thing you might forget is we don’t export population, we export actual manufactured goods, medicine, advanced electronics, aviation equipment, automotive, airbag sensors etc.
I’d argue the problems The West ™ is facing are mostly due to late stage capitalism rather than the sanctions against Russia. We can get our dinosaur products elsewhere.
I’m looking forward to what the future might bring for all of us. Don’t forget we live on the same planet. And keep an open mind.
Edit for effortpost: the fact that late stage capitalism and impotent sanctions coincide is no coincidence. I find LSC a poorly defined term, considering that imperialism seems NOT be considered in the term but only internal indications, but I digress. These two developments, one of corruption from capital and crises developing and the other of sanctions having no benefit and only seeing blowback, are dialectically intertwined. Sanctions could work if western imperialism hadn’t developed to an extent that all necessary labour can be done outside of the core for cheaper. But the efforts to maintain the standards of living and fight external pressure are resulting from the same process and the failures are inseparable also
Thanks for the edit.
I’d be willing to say:
mostly due to
late stagecapitalismBut I’m not sold on the imperialism aspect when both parties are doing it. Although I’d distinguish if they’re doing it with the pen or with the sword. It’d be better without, but I sure do prefer the pen.
Meh, I disagree but this is too tangential from the rest of the thread for me to work too hard in a response. Not sure what you’re even arguing tbh, except that peaceful imperialism is different and America does that. I think all facts point to that being absolutely false, even if the violence is done quietly and in a normalized fashion. I also just disagree that Russia here is Imperialist with a big “I” (different from having a empire, which is confusing often). I also have no idea what this has to do with whether sanctions are succeeding or failing or not. My point is only that the failure of the sanctions and the results of capitalism are from the identical source which is capitalism and the logic of that extended through imperialism to international relations
You realize that IMF and pretty much everyone else now says that it’s growing, but I guess you just want to cling to your narrative by cherry picking a paragraph from an article that fits into what you believe.
And Russia is primarily a commodities exporter, however it does export a significant amount of manufactured goods as well https://tradingeconomics.com/russia/exports
What’s more though is that domestic factory activity in Russia is now growing which is the opposite of what’s happening in Germany https://www.reuters.com/markets/europe/russian-factory-activity-expands-april-export-orders-pick-up-2023-05-02/
Yeah, and cheap energy from Russia was the reason Germany was able to produce these things competitively. Now, input costs for German manufacturing are surging leading to deindustrialization as companies move operations to cheaper energy markets. This is how capitalism works.
Late stage capitalism is obviously the underlying reason why the west as a whole is failing. However, having a significant increase in energy costs is clearly a catalyst for the current disaster that Europe is experiencing. These things are in no way mutually exclusive. The economy was structured around cheap energy and doing a lot of trade with Russia and China. Now all of a sudden cheap energy from Russia is gone, and US is leaning on Europe to decouple from China. This is a huge economic readjustment that’s happening rapidly. This is leading to companies closing down, jobs being lost, living expenses going up, and so on.
We do live on the same planet, and that’s precisely why the west needs to start treating the rest of humanity on equal terms instead of trying to dominate the world. Western policies are directly responsible for the climate catastrophe, and western lifestyle continues to be one of the primary drivers of global emissions. Instead of focusing on this global disaster that affects us all, the west decided to fight a proxy war with Russia, and US is increasingly trying to provoke a conflict with China now. People living in the west really need to do some self reflection.