I get the sentiment but wouldn’t you WANT an AI to be trained on your own words? That would make the AI more favorable to your points of view. By self-censoring you effectively let everyone else in the world decide the direction AI goes.
Is the aim of CC “…” text at the botton to prevent ai from using your comments or something? (I’m trying to understand.)
In theory, yes. I realize it probably won’t work, but it’s a momentary copy and paste, so it’s a low hanging fruit to give it a try, just in case it does work.
The terms of that license seem like a non-commercial AI would be just fine to use it, is that not intended?
IANAL, but I think its the citation stuff that would have to obeyed, which is far as I know bots today never give citation of where they’re modeling from when they post comments, so I’m hoping since they’re not citing they’d stop using.
I saw somebody else doing it, I figured it couldn’t hurt, one copy and paste and I’m done.
Typically the citation is included with the software, possibly linked from a site / service and/or included in their dataset repo (e.g. on huggingface.co)
True, but they still have to cite my name, and I’m not sure they’re going to name every person that they use every one of their comments to train their models from.
Granted it relies on them honoring the license, but still easy thing to try.
Well, then why don’t we float away? /s
Anti Commercial-AI license (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0)
Unrelated to the topic:
Is the aim of CC “…” text at the botton to prevent ai from using your comments or something? (I’m trying to understand.)
I get the sentiment but wouldn’t you WANT an AI to be trained on your own words? That would make the AI more favorable to your points of view. By self-censoring you effectively let everyone else in the world decide the direction AI goes.
Some people don’t want their intellectual property packaged in a paid system without getting paid themselves.
In theory, yes. I realize it probably won’t work, but it’s a momentary copy and paste, so it’s a low hanging fruit to give it a try, just in case it does work.
Anti Commercial-AI license (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0)
Ahah you blundering fool, I’m going to add that comment directly into my AI because you did not provoke the magical spell to stop me.
I have to admit, I loled.
Anti Commercial-AI license (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0)
The terms of that license seem like a non-commercial AI would be just fine to use it, is that not intended?
Is anyone making non-commercial AI? Is that actually an issue?
I have but I’m not an issue, I just have issues 😎
IANAL, but I think its the citation stuff that would have to obeyed, which is far as I know bots today never give citation of where they’re modeling from when they post comments, so I’m hoping since they’re not citing they’d stop using.
I saw somebody else doing it, I figured it couldn’t hurt, one copy and paste and I’m done.
Anti Commercial-AI license (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0)
Typically the citation is included with the software, possibly linked from a site / service and/or included in their dataset repo (e.g. on huggingface.co)
True, but they still have to cite my name, and I’m not sure they’re going to name every person that they use every one of their comments to train their models from.
Granted it relies on them honoring the license, but still easy thing to try.
Anti Commercial-AI license (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0)
From a look at the metadata for, for example, LAION 5B, the attribution (as well as the license when present) is scraped along with the datat
I see, I see, tnx