Don’t mean to cause an argument war in the comments so please stay civil. But it’s an interesting read.
You must log in or register to comment.
Whenever I hear of that group, I think “oh, those nutcases”, and not “heroic deeds for nature”.
I am convinced they are actually run by big oil to make real environmentalist look bad, and create a path for harsher punishment and criminalisation of climate protests everywhere. So far, they have been quite successful in that regard.
Who are the real environmentalists?
Those who actually do something to save the nature instead of throwing soup at paintings for media attention.
Who is doing a good job of that?
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greta_Thunberg Or the people who go around getting signatures, but they don’t cause a ton of controversy so you won’t see them
Is it working?
Just Stop Oil feels like an astroturf group made by fossil fuel lobbyists to smear the idea of activists while teaching a generation how to fuck up protesting. Their wildly unreliable activities make me not trust them for defacing unrelated things like art. There are other, better ways to protest. And besides, coal is more destructive than oil so this group doesn’t look like they know about environmental sciences. Britain was built on coal - fix that first. It’s already dying, just do the world a favor and finish it off.
What are the other better ways to protest?
Interfere with the industry that it is trying to upset. Frustrating the customers does little to stop the supply/demand of the market so oil keeps being produced and used.
Disrupt oil production. Upset oil deliveries. Frustrate the oil users.
Those are the end objectives that will change how the world uses oil. Now the organization name makes sense - it’s the start and sole cause of the movement. Now it can galvanize people to join by knowing the cause through a name that is a call to action. JSO does so much almost right that it feels like deliberate missteps each time JSO is in the news.
JSO can organize union drives to upset oil production. Rally the people behind it and the organization may see change from the inside. Or at least freak out the people in charge enough to see they need to change.
Dig troughs across oil access roads so maintenance crews can’t get to rigs. Make the cost of running the business so high that the people making decisions have to start addressing the activity. Frustrate the business.
Throwing soup at an icon of culture does nothing to highlight the goals, rally support, or stop the offending action. It ONLY gives oil protests a bad name while being completely unhelpful at stopping oil.
Interfere with the industry that it is trying to upset.
That just gets you shot and/or arrested in the middle of nowhere.
You need some media participation.
Edit and/or
It looks like Just Stop Oil does all of those things according to their Wiki entry: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just_Stop_Oil
And all I ever see on the news is soup on art. So what do you suggest now?
Stop throwing soup on art and keep fighting fossil fuels. Go after coal too. Power plants and refineries are choke points on the process. Just stop making the public mad with pointless soup throwing. Or at least throw it on Nigel Farage. Public figures need soup more than Renaissance painters.
The defacement of treasured art is what ruined it for me. Throwing paint on a centuries-old work of art tells me more about how you see your relative worth in the world than it tells me about some cause I just stopped ever wanting to support.
It’s as gauche as scratching your initials into the colosseum, and worse when one drags an organization down too.
They have never defaced a single piece of art.
Did they actually do that? They threw soup at a pane of glass.
A YouTuber I quite like, Tom Nicholas, recently made a video going undercover with Just Stop Oil. Warning, it’s an hour long video, but he has interesting analysis of JSO’s actions and he includes the perspective of their members as to why they do what they do.
jeez, their protests are terrible. and they kept getting worse as I kept reading.
